Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shot Recipe | Easy Halloween Shot Recipe (2024)

Jump to Recipe

What’s orange, black and topped with a miniature mountain of whipped cream? It’s none other than my easy peasy Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shot Recipe. This Halloween-inspired jello shot recipe is not only perfect for your yearly Halloween party but it’s just as amazing on any night of the week during the Halloween season.

*Originally posted: 9/6/2019

Who said Halloween was just for kids?! If it were up to me, I’d still be out there on October 31st knocking on doors for Twix bars, Twizzlers, and Reese’s peanut butter cups galore. Those are my absolute favorites!

What is your favorite Halloween candy? My husband, Patrick, goes crazy for Snickers and our son, Zach, is a huge fan of Sour Patch Kids and Almond Joys.

Although I’m too grown for those Trick-or-Treating shenanigans anymore, I’m the perfect age for these Halloween creamsicle jello shots. And you are too if you’re over 21 that is!

Remember that delicious creamsicle ice pop you devoured during the hot summer months as a child?! Well, I’ve taken that same flavor profile and created a Halloween treat just for us adults.

What can I say, I was kind of tired of being left out…

Want to know the best part? It literally takes 5 minutes to put these creamsicle jello shots together. The hardest part is having to wait the 3 to 4 hours for the jello to set. I’d have to say it’s equally as frustrating as being a child on Halloween night and your parents not letting you eat ALL your candy in one sitting. I’m sure you’ve been there!

It takes patience, friends, but you can do it. I have faith in you!

When creating this jello shot recipe, I had to do the torturous job of taste testing a few in order to find the perfect combination of jello to vodka. It was a dreadful experience that I can vaguely remember because of all the alcohol I consumed…

I’m totally kidding you!The amount of alcohol is pretty minimal in these shots unless you consume all 12 on your own in one sitting. One cup of whipped cream vodka might be a little more than some can handle so show some restraint as hard as it may be.

In regards to the perfect combination of whipped cream vodka to jello, here are my two cents:

Here’s what you need to make this Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shot Recipe

*Note: This recipe will make 12 Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shots. Feel free to double, triple, etc. all the ingredients if you’re making these for a party or large crowd.

3 oz. box of orange jello, 1 cup of orange soda (I used Fanta), 1 cup of whipped cream vodka (I used Pinnacle), whipped cream, black sugar/sprinkles, jello shot containers

Begin by laying out your jello shot containers. I found that placing them inside a cupcake pan made the transition from in and out the refrigerator so much easier. It just helps keep everything in place and spares you from losing precious drops of creamsicle heaven.

Next, bring one cup of orange soda to a boil. You’ll notice that the soda will sound like it’s popping throughout the entirety of it being on the stovetop. This is normal. You’ll know when the orange soda is at an actual boil when you see smoke coming from the pan and the liquid is rolling around like waves.

Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shot Recipe | Easy Halloween Shot Recipe (7)

While the soda is coming to a boil, empty your package of orange jello into a heat-safe bowl.

Once the soda comes to a boil, add it to the orange jello powder and whisk away until the powder completely dissolves.

You’ll then want to grab your whipped cream vodka and add one cup to the jello mixture.

Ingredients

3 oz. box of orange jello, 1 cup of orange soda (I used Fanta), 1 cup of whipped cream vodka, whipped cream, black sugar/sprinkles, jello shot containers

Instructions

Begin by laying out your jello shot containers. I found that placing them inside a cupcake pan made the transition in and out of the refrigerator so much easier.
Next, bring one cup of orange soda to a boil. You’ll notice that the soda will sound like it’s popping throughout the entirety of it being on the stovetop. This is normal. You’ll know when the orange soda is at an actual boil when you see smoke coming from the pan and the liquid is rolling around like waves.
While the soda is coming to a boil, empty your package of orange jello into a heat-safe bowl.
Once the soda comes to a boil, add it to the orange jello powder and whisk away until the powder completely dissolves.
You’ll then want to grab your whipped cream vodka and add one cup to the jello mixture.
Transfer the liquid to a measuring cup or a bowl with a spout. This will save you from having a tremendous mess when pouring the liquid into the shot containers.
Pour the liquid into the shot containers leaving some space on the top to add your whipped cream once the jello thickens.
Place the jello shots in the refrigerator and let them set for 3 to 4 hours. *You can make these the night before your party too!
If you don’t plan on serving immediately, place the lids on top of your shots until it’s time to get the party started. The lids are also helpful if you’re transporting the shots to another location.
Right before serving, add a healthy helping of whipped cream on top and dust with black sugar or sprinkles.

Notes

For a jello shot with less alcohol, substitute 1/2 a cup of the whipped cream vodka with 1/2 a cup of water.

Want to remember this? Post my Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shot Recipe to your favorite Pinterest board!

Thirsty Thursday

Halloween Creamsicle Jello Shots
Cinnamon Roll co*cktail
Apple Cider Mimosa Recipe
Spiked Hot Apple Cider with Fireball Whiskey
White Sangria with Peach Schnapps and Triple Sec
Strawberry Lemonade Vodka Popsicles
Cake Mix Kahula and Amaretto Infused Cupcakes
Spiked Disney Dole Whip with Coconut Rum
Fruity White Wine Slushies
Spiked Root Beer Float
Sand Bucket co*cktail
Cruzan Tropical Fruit Rum
Easy Patriotic Mimosa Recipe
Frozen Banana Daiquiri Recipe
Banana Coconut Rum Punch
3 Ingredient Watermelon Vodka Slush
Pineapple Sex on the Beach Drink Recipe
8 Low-Calorie Delicious Flavored Vodka Soda Ideas
White Claw Wine Spritzer
Fruity Fuzzy Navel
Pineapple Paradise Mimosa plus Mocktail Recipe
Blackberry Mojitos
Strawberry Vodka Lemonade

FAQs

What's the best alcohol to use for jello shots? ›

A lighter flavor like white rum will still allow the jello taste to be dominant, but you can also use stronger tasting options like gin, whiskey, or tequila, if that's your preference or goes best with your flavor profile (like tequila for a Strawberry Margarita Jello Shot, etc.).

Explore More ›

When making jello shots do you replace the water for alcohol? ›

Their key takeaways:

A standard recipe made with 3 ounces of Jell-O powder calls for 5 ounces of 80-proof vodka and 11 ounces of water, but this results in a shot that tastes watered-down.
To make a stronger shot, use just 4 ounces of water and between 8 and 14 ounces of vodka (to taste)

More items...

Find Out More ›

Do you need to spray cups for jello shots? ›

Place shot glasses on a baking tray for easy transport. Pour gelatin mixture into paper or plastic shot cups* and chill in refrigerator until set, 1 hour or more. *Reviewers suggest coating the shot cups lightly with cooking spray so the shots slide right out.

Should alcohol be cold when making jello shots? ›

Note: The colder your alcohol is, the better the result. I think this has to do with the activation of the gelatin. Personally, when possible, I keep the bottle of alcohol in the freezer for several days before making my shots.

How many jello shots does a 6 oz box make? ›

1 small box of jello yields about 15 jello shots (2 cups of liquid). 2 boxes (or 1 large 6 oz. box) yield 30 shots, which will fit nicely on a baking sheet to transport them easily to the refrigerator.

Get More Info Here ›

How do you make jello shots slide out easily? ›

Simply spritz cooking spray around the interior of your jello shot containers, and use a paper towel to spread it around so that all that's left is a light coating. To eat, use your finger to scoop out the jello shot and it should release from the cup much easier.

See Details ›

Should I flip jello shots upside down? ›

That's where a new trick comes into play that promises to make downing those Jell-O shots at the party so much easier to consume: turn the shot upside down to prevent the Jell-O from sticking to the cup.

Find Out More ›

Should you store jello shots upside down? ›

Or, if you are serving your shots out of plastic cups with lids, you can store them upside down in the fridge as they set. This way, the shot itself will be at the top of the cup and more accessible. If you go this route, you should also keep the shots in a large storage bin in case of leaks.

Explore More ›

Why do you flip jello shots upside down? ›

To do it, simply pour your liquid Jell-O shot into the cups, add the lid, and then flip each one before refrigerating. The result is a shot that sticks to the lid rather than the edges of the cup, allowing you easy access to that Jell-O goodness and making it so much easier to slurp down.

Do jello shots get stronger the longer they sit? ›

Jello Shots, like life, are all about balance. That said, if you want a strong one, it is possible if you leave it in the fridge long enough. In a Supercall experiment, we found that the strongest Jello Shot that will set is three-to-one ratio of 80-proof alcohol to water, and it took a full day to become mostly solid.

Get More Info ›

How long do jello shots have to sit in the fridge? ›

If you're wondering how long it will take for your jello shots to set, it depends on which type you make, but a general rule is two to four hours. A basic jello shot recipe should be allowed to set in the fridge for at least two hours. Four hours is better.